The Fed Isn’t Bluffing: The Actual Risk of an Upside-Down Depression


“Shortly after October 6, 1979, [US Federal Reserve chair Paul Volcker] met with some chief executives of medium-sized corporations. . . . One CEO introduced that he had lately signed a three-year labor contract with annual wage will increase of 13 p.c — and was proud of the outcome. Only bitter expertise would purge inflationary expectations and habits. ‘Credibility’ needed to be received by means of struggling. That was primarily the Volcker program.” — Robert J. Samuelson, The Great Inflation and Its Aftermath

Will the US Federal Reserve abandon its aggressive contractionary financial coverage as soon as markets start to capitulate? Many buyers hope so. But given the elemental circumstances at play, we’d be smart to dispense with such fantasies. The Fed is unlikely to shelve its coverage prematurely. That means we must always put together for financial ache extra extreme than any we’ve got skilled over the previous decade.

To perceive why the Fed is unlikely to again down, we first want to grasp the gravity of the risk.

A Depression Turned Upside-Down

The United States has skilled durations of excessive inflation lasting longer than a 12 months simply six occasions since 1800. In all however one case, the first driver was a full navy mobilization or the speedy aftermath of such a mobilization. This, in fact, was intentional: Wars are simpler to fund by printing cash and debasing the foreign money than by elevating taxes.

So, what was the one obvious exception to this sample? The Great Inflation of 1968 to 1982. Flawed financial coverage was the clear wrongdoer right here. A misguided Fed succumbed to stress from politicians of each events who favored unemployment discount over value stability.

US Inflation Rate, 1800 to 2020

Chart showing US Inflation Rate, 1800 to 2020Source: Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis

The Fed’s errant philosophy throughout this period traces again to the Phillips Curve idea. Economists of the day believed there was a secure trade-off between inflation and unemployment and that decrease unemployment may very well be achieved in change for barely greater inflation. But what Phillips Curve adherents didn’t perceive was that whereas a trade-off did exist, it was solely non permanent. When unemployment fell beneath its pure charge, it established a brand new baseline of anticipated inflation, and unemployment charges finally returned to earlier ranges. The Fed would loosen financial coverage once more when unemployment elevated, and inflation would spike every time. In pursuit of unsustainably low unemployment, the Fed created a vicious cycle: The nation suffered each excessive unemployment and excessive inflation, or “stagflation.”

This upside-down melancholy was as painful as a deflationary melancholy, however it got here with a persistent improve in costs moderately than a decline. This was the elemental dynamic underlying the Great Inflation.

Tile for Puzzles of Inflation, Money, and Debt: Applying the Fiscal Theory of the Price Level

Few who lived by means of the Great Inflation have fond recollections of its financial results. From 1968 to 1982, the United States skilled 4 recessions. High inflation dragged down actual wages: Workers had greater paychecks however much less buying energy. Home loans and business loans grew more and more unaffordable as lenders raised charges to compensate for greater inflation expectations.

Meanwhile, inventory returns have been abysmal. Investors demanded better returns relative to rising rates of interest, and price-to-earnings ratios plummeted. Price instability stunted enterprise funding and operational effectivity, resulting in sharp declines in productiveness. The hopelessness was paying homage to the Great Depression. The distress index, which provides the inflation charge and the unemployment charge, bears this out. During the Great Inflation, the metric wasn’t far faraway from the place it had been through the Great Depression, averaging 13.6% from 1968 to 1982 versus 16.3% through the Thirties.

US Misery Index, 1929 to 2021

Chart showing US Misery Index, 1929 to 2021Sources: United States Misery Index; Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis; Department of Labor Statistics
The official distress index begins in 1948. The unemployment and inflation knowledge used to calculate the metric pre-1948 use a unique methodology. Nevertheless, the overall development is probably going directionally appropriate.

Messaging from politicians made the state of affairs worse. They refused to query their financial assumptions and as a substitute blamed inflation on exogenous occasions like oil embargoes and the Vietnam War. Yet when these shocks subsided, inflation remained. Retrospective evaluation of this occasion revealed that these weren’t important causal elements; they solely elevated inflation on the margins. The main trigger was persistent, overly accommodative financial coverage.

It was solely when Volcker, backed by President Ronald Reagan, started his relentless marketing campaign to shrink the cash provide that the Fed re-established its credibility and at last ended the Great Inflation. Of course, Volcker’s marketing campaign was not with out value. The nation suffered a dreadful recession from 1981 to 1982 because the federal funds charge peaked at 20% in June 1981 and unemployment at 10.8% in 1982. The nation paid a steep value for 14 years of financial profligacy. It just isn’t one thing US central bankers will simply overlook or willingly repeat.

Book jackets of Financial Market History: Reflections on the Past for Investors Today

Preventing an Upside-Down Depression

The Fed’s present management deserves some empathy for the challenges it has confronted because the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. First, in March 2020, with the assistance of considerable fiscal stimulus, it staved off a second Great Depression, and now, simply two years later, it should counter a possible second Great Inflation. And stopping the latter in 2022 is simply as necessary as stopping the previous was in 2020, even when the countermeasures are exactly the other. Giving individuals more cash forestalled a return to the Thirties; avoiding a return to the Nineteen Seventies would require taking cash away.

The Fed is already a step behind. It admittedly misjudged the persistence of post-COVID-19 inflation late final 12 months. So, extra draconian insurance policies could also be required to make up for earlier missteps. And time is operating out. The longer inflation persists, the extra expectations will shift upward and the upper the price of reversing the inflationary spiral.

Future Outlook

Make no mistake; the Fed is aware of why the Great Inflation occurred and the way painful a possible rerun of it could be. It will do what must be completed to forestall such a disaster.

There isn’t any such factor as absolute certainty in investing. Human beings are fallible, and financial elements are unpredictable. But it could be ill-advised to wager towards the Fed’s sincerity on this case. Rather, we must always put together for financial tightening that can persist till costs stabilize. Such a situation is tough to examine with no painful recession and additional market declines.

Financial Analysts Journal Current Issue Tile

Volcker restored the Fed’s credibility within the early Nineteen Eighties by means of struggling. The Fed of 2022 is aware of that it should pursue an identical course immediately. While the struggling is inevitable, when and the way extreme will probably be is not possible to know with precision. Indeed, those that would speculate ought to keep in mind Volcker’s admonition:

“There is a prudent maxim of the financial forecaster’s commerce that’s too usually ignored: decide a quantity or decide a date, however by no means each.”

If you preferred this submit, don’t overlook to subscribe to the Enterprising Investor.

All posts are the opinion of the writer. As such, they shouldn’t be construed as funding recommendation, nor do the opinions expressed essentially replicate the views of CFA Institute or the writer’s employer.

Image credit score: ©Getty Images/P_Wei

Professional Learning for CFA Institute Members

CFA Institute members are empowered to self-determine and self-report skilled studying (PL) credit earned, together with content material on Enterprising Investor. Members can document credit simply utilizing their on-line PL tracker.

Mark J. Higgins, CFA

Mark J. Higgins, CFA, CFP® is a seasoned funding adviser with greater than a dozen years of expertise serving massive institutional buyers, similar to endowments, foundations, public pension plans, and company working reserves. He can also be an avid monetary historian and is publishing a e-book on the total historical past of the US monetary system in early 2023. Higgins obtained a grasp’s of enterprise administration from the Darden School of Business and graduated Phi Beta Kappa from Georgetown University with bachelors’ of arts levels in English and psychology. He can also be a CFA® charterholder and CFP® skilled.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here